Friday, April 18, 2008

The My Beautiful Mommy Controversy

Forget the stories about Paris Hilton swearing she'll never get breast augmentation and Kate Beckingsale swearing she's never had it. Those stories are tame compared to what's the new Flavor of the Week.

In a children's book, aimed at four to seven year olds, a mother tries to reassure her daughter about why she's getting a tummy tuck, breast augmentation (implied by the pictures showing the mother's breasts change from the beginning to the end), and nose job. These are all part of the "mommy makeover."

Written by a Florida board-certified cosmetic surgeon named Michael Salzhuaer, My Beautiful Mommy is advertised as a way to explain to young kids why their mom 1) is coming home bruised and bandaged, 2) will look different, and 3) why the mommy makeover was necessary in the first place. Dr. Salzhuaer states that it was written in response to witnessing kids coming into the office with their mothers when they were looking into having cosmetic surgery. The book has the typical text written for young kids, as well as pictures of what has been described as a mother shaped like a Barbie doll, and a doctor ("Dr. Michael") who looks a little like Superman. By the end of the book, the daughter is pleased with the fact that her mom looks "even more" beautiful.

Helpful or Hurtful?

Some mothers have found the book to be helpful. One mother, Gabriela Acosta, saw the manuscript when she went to talk to Salzhauer. She didn't know how to explain to her son what was going to happen to her. Acosta states that it helped her son move from scared to excited.

President of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, Richard D'Amico, gives the book mixed reviews. On the one hand, the believes that the book lets prospective patients know that there is a way to tell their kids what's going on - if they choose to tell their kids anything. On the other hand, he believes the breasts of the mother look "overdone." Most mothers, he claims, are only looking for restoration. He apparently had no comment on Super Doctor Michael's picture.

Those who find the book problematic include both the popular blog sites www.feministing.com and www.huffingtonpost.com. Along with these sites, and their readers, others are wondering, why, on God's green earth, is there a book being marketed to children about cosmetic surgery? While some find the book a little funny, others seem to be appalled. The central argument is wondering why children as young as four-years-old should know about these procedures. The counterargument being, isn't it better to explain to children why their mothers are resting for a few days, seem a little groggy, and might look different than ignore it? Well, sure, we'll buy that.

Yet, perhaps cosmetic surgery's media fascination has jumped the shark. We're already inundated with who-is-getting-what-done all the time. We're told teens are getting cosmetic surgery at a (seemingly) astronomical rate. There are stories about 13-year-olds who want breast augmentation for their birthdays, mothers who tell their kids they may have to consider these things to get ahead in the future, and now a book explaining this to kids who have just begun their education.

Appalling? Perhaps. Genius? Eh. Sign of the times? Definitely.

But, once upon a time, a book called Where Do I Come From? appeared so that parents could read to their kids a nice, non-scientific, un-pornographic description of sex. There might have been biology and facts of life there, and it's certainly more natural than cosmetic surgery. But in the end, isn't it a mother's prerogative to wonder about cosmetic surgery? After all, it's the kid's fault their mom needs a mommy makeover in the first place.

If you are interested in mommy makeovers or other cosmetic surgery procedures, please contact an experienced cosmetic surgeon in your area.

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Advertising Thinness May Become a Crime in France

Due to the proliferation of websites that promote anorexia and bulimia, French legislators have proposed a bill that will punish magazines or websites with three years in prison and over $70,000 in fines if they continue to show the benefits of the disorders. Since 2000, over 400 sites promoting "ana" and "mia" have been identified. These sites offer tips on bingeing, crash dieting, vomiting, and hiding weight loss from parents, many of whom are already concerned about their children.

Sponsored by Valerie Boyer, a conservative, the measure was also backed by Roselyne Bachelot, France's health minister. Measures of this caliber have been proposed since Brazilian model, Ana Carolina Reston, died of anorexia in 2006. However, this is the one of the more strongly worded measures to come before the lower house of Parliament. The bill makes illegal to "provoke a person to seek excessive weight loss by encouraging prolonged nutritional deprivation that would have the effect of exposing them to risk of death or endangering health."

Blame

Ms. Boyer blamed the "sociocultural and media environment" for favoring anorexic and bulimic behavior, and believes it necessary to act. This was criticized by the French Federation of Couture. Federation president, Didier Grumbach, states, "Never will we accept in our profession that a judge decides if a young girl is skinny or not skinny….That doesn't exist in the world, and it will certainly not exist in France." The French Socialist Party has also complained that the bill, which they believe is vaguely worded, was rushed through the lower house by President Nicolas Sarkozy's political party, the U.M.P.

Two Cents

While it is certainly a personal choice on how much weight one wants to lose, promoting anorexia and bulimia as a lifestyle seems at least misguided, and at most, possibly criminal. Society seems to already be reeling with the fact that so many young people are seeking cosmetic surgery, and this is obviously taking the urge to look "perfect" in a horrible new direction. If you have ever known anyone who has suffered anorexia or bulimia, then you know it isn't something to be promoted. It's an illness, and those with it need professional medical care. More often than not, those who suffer with these illnesses wish they could stop after they've done it for a while.

Teenage girls are more likely to succumb to the temptation to binge or starve in an effort to be as thin as waifish fashion models, just as they are more likely to seek out cosmetic surgeons. However, breast implants on an anorexic or bulimic frame 1) would look really bad, and 2) would never happen since your health is evaluated before having any type of cosmetic procedure. You can't have it both ways.

Perhaps the French could take a page from American cosmetic surgically crazed kids and go under the knife rather than starve themselves in private. After all, the end result is the hope to be seen in a positive light. And no one likes it when someone smells like vomit.

If you are interested in cosmetic surgery, please contact an experienced cosmetic surgeon in your area.

Labels: , , , ,

Disclaimer: The information throughout The Cosmetic Surgery Directory is not intended to be taken as plastic surgery advice. The information throughout The Cosmetic Surgeon Directory is intended to provide general information regarding cosmetic surgery and to help you find a local cosmetic surgeon. If you are interested in cosmetic surgery, contact a cosmetic surgeon in your area.